Compare
Free shipping
Best price guarantee
SimpleCrew exclusive savings
0% financing options
Tire replacement coverage
24/7 roadside assistance
Easy returns
Last updated 7/17/2024 - Originally published 7/17/2024
Written by SimpleTire
All-season tires are great as a versatile solution for most drivers. That means all-season tires deliver dependable grip year-round, excellent wear properties with generous limited manufacturer’s tread life coverage, a quiet and refined ride, polished road manners, and capable handling. For drivers of performance-oriented vehicles who really want to push things to the limit, though, too many times all-season tires fall a little short of what they need. Summer and ultra-high-performance (UHP) tires are the answer in those instances; they’re designed for steering response, braking and cornering performance that most all-season tires can’t quite measure up to.
In this head-to-head comparison, we’re going to look at the Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3, a great all-season tire with UHP design elements, and the Vogue Signature V Black. It’s a little unusual; everyone knows Pirelli and their reputation for performance, but Vogue tires are often associated more with Grand Touring and all-season tires for luxury cars (as well as stylish sidewall treatments).
In the course of this comparison review, we’ll refer to SimpleScore ratings for both tires. If you’re not acquainted with it already, SimpleScore is the proprietary rating system that was devised by the SimpleTire team to give you a quick, at-a-glance idea of any tire’s strengths and weaknesses. We take into account the tire’s technical details, specs, manufacturer info, customer reviews, and other data points, and then that all gets processed to a 1-10 numerical value for the categories of traction, handling, and longevity, along with an overall average SimpleScore number. For the Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3 and Vogue Signature V Black, the SimpleScore rankings break down like this:
Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3:
- Traction: 9.9
- Handling: 9.9
- Longevity: 8.9
- Overall average SimpleScore: 9.5
Vogue Signature V Black:
- Traction: 8.8
- Handling: 9.1
- Longevity: 9.0
- Overall average SimpleScore: 8.8
As you can see, there are some notable disparities in the SimpleScore rankings of these two tires. As handy as SimpleScore is, though, it’s the 30,000 foot view that doesn’t tell the whole story and only gives you the rough outlines of what a tire can deliver. Let’s go in and get a closer look with this Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3 vs Vogue Signature V Black comparison review:
Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3 tires
First, let’s talk about the Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3, an all-season tire that’s designed for enthusiastic performance along with reliable year-round all-season traction. Pirelli designed the P Zero All Season Plus 3 starting from the ground up with an updated polymer-enhanced tread formulation for durability and long wear. The result is a tire that’s grippy and secure on the corners or the track, keeping your vehicle practically glued to the road during hard maneuvers. Stability and wear properties are quite good, with a twin steel belt package, a polyester casing, and polyamide reinforcement plies. Pirelli stands by the P Zero All Season Plus 3 with a 50,000-mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty. The year-round grip is one of the real strong points of this tire, with an asymmetric tread pattern that features a minimal void area and a contact patch that’s enhanced to put more rubber in contact with the road. Superb grip and performance in wet or wintry conditions come from a variety of sipes, grooves, and channels, including full-depth 3D sipes in select tread blocks. Twin steel belts with a polyester casing and twin polyamide reinforcement plies give the Pirelli outstanding control and road manners at high speeds. Enhanced steering response, braking, and cornering are pretty admirable, thanks to larger pitch-sequenced tread blocks and reinforced shoulders. SimpleTire’s price on the Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3 starts at $185.47 per tire.
Vogue Signature V Black tires
With the Signature V Black, Vogue has developed a tire that’s nicely balanced - it’s got the kind of handling properties, steering response, and braking performance that enthusiasts love, along with ride quality, low noise, and road manners that make it a great fit for high-end sedans and luxury SUVs and crossovers. The Signature V Black is designed around a silica-rich tread compound that helps deliver excellent traction along with great wear properties (Vogue covers the Signature V Black with a 60,000-mile limited manufacturer’s tread life warranty). Four circumferential grooves with a 10/32” initial tread depth are designed for dependable grip in wet or wintry conditions, and the innovative tread design of the Vogue features angled grooves and sipes that boost wet-weather performance. The reinforced shoulder blocks and continuous center rib of the Signature V Black give it handling and steering responses that are accurate and capable, and Vogue’s Whisper Tuning and Comfort Ride technology packages help ensure a ride that’s refined and quiet. Vogue claims braking distances that are 10% shorter than the leading competitors’ tires. Like the Pirelli, the internal construction details of the Vogue Signature V Black include a polyester casing with twin steel belts and a nylon cap ply.
Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3 vs Vogue Signature V Black tires on traction
How do the Vogue and the Pirelli stack up against each other when it comes to traction? It’s not even really close in that category; Vogue’s respectable SimpleScore of 8.8 is blown out of the water by Pirelli’s 9.9. That’s due almost entirely to the Pirelli’s network of sipes and grooves for enhanced traction in winter weather. The Pirelli’s not a winter tire or all-weather tire, and of course, neither the Pirelli nor the Vogue are 3 Peak Mountain Snowflake rated for severe winter service. Pirelli’s design team did have their minds on winter performance with this tire, though, and of course, any tire that performs well in winter conditions will generally do well on rainy pavement as well. Our decision:
ADVANTAGE: Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3
Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3 vs Vogue Signature V Black tires on handling
Handling and traction are tied in pretty closely with each other; after all, if you can’t get a good grip on a wet or dry road, you run the risk of oversteering or understeering as you go into a curve and are going to have a hard time with control. That’s the case here; the Pirelli shows great SimpleScore numbers for traction and registers a 9.9 for handling vs the 9.1 for the Vogue. A 9.1 is still a pretty strong score, obviously, but the Vogue doesn’t have the crisp, motorsports-inspired handling properties that the Pirelli can deliver. While the handling and braking performance of the Vogue are pretty admirable, the Pirelli feels like it’d be right at home on a track. Our call:
ADVANTAGE: Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3
Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3 vs Vogue Signature V Black tires on longevity
Now we come to the longevity category, where the Vogue edges out the Pirelli with a SimpleScore of 9.1 vs 8.9 for the Pirelli. It makes sense, usually the SimpleScore for longevity is tied directly to the tire’s mileage warranty. The Vogue Signature V Black is covered by a 60,000-mile limited manufacturer’s tread life warranty vs 50,000 miles for the Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3, so that’s a no-brainer. Our call?
ADVANTAGE: Vogue Signature V Black
When to use each
So let’s just talk for a minute about your vehicle, your driving style, and your needs. If you’re in a part of the country that has several inches of snow every winter (snow that might linger on the roads for days at a time), neither the Pirelli nor the Vogue is probably going to be a great choice, so let’s just get that out of the way right off. If, however, you like a nice composed ride quality and dependable grip on wet or dry roads along with sporty handling, the Vogue and the Pirelli would both make a great choice for you. They both offer long tread life and great road manners along with their handling and braking performance, and both tires would be an excellent option for a sporty sedan or crossover.
Which one should you choose?
While Pirelli handily beats Vogue in the SimpleScore categories, it’s a bit of an apples/oranges comparison in one particular aspect. Vogue’s Grand Touring tires are designed for luxurious ride quality and a whisper-quiet ride, and the Signature V Black is no exception. It might lag a little behind the Pirelli when it comes to handling ability, steering response, and braking performance, but it also is designed for a quieter and less firm ride. If you’re looking for capable handling along with a refined ride, we think that the Vogue Signature V Black could be a great choice for your vehicle. If you want a year-round grip along with a somewhat less forgiving ride and white-knuckle adrenalin-squirting handling, the Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus 3 might be the right tire choice for you.
Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.