BlackHawk Agility SUV vs Summit Trail Climber SUV2 tires

BlackHawk is a part of Sailun Tire Group and has its footprints in over 40 nations. The value-driven tire brand offers quality tires at competitive prices for a variety of vehicles, including passenger cars, light trucks, and SUVs. The tire manufacturer emphasizes dependable year-round performance in many of its lines and features them with modern designs. The tires offered by BlackHawk focus on the essential needs of drivers who seek reliable traction and adequate durability without breaking the bank.

Summit, on the other hand, was founded in 1974 and is owned by the Tire Alliance Group. It offers a broad portfolio of tires that cover a significant portion of the replacement market in the US. Known for utilizing advanced engineering and feature-rich designs, Summit provides reliable solutions for daily driving, hauling, and load-carrying across multiple vehicle segments. Whether you need all-seasons, all-weathers, all-terrains, or a different set of tires, Summit’s offerings come with an assurance of dependable performance.

In the all-season tire category, the BlackHawk Agility SUV and the Summit Trail Climber SUV2 are the two close competitors. While the Agility SUV is a performance-oriented all-season tire specifically engineered for use on SUVs and CUVs to provide a balanced highway ride and dependable grip year-round, the Trail Climber SUV2 is a robust all-season tire suitable for SUVs and CUVs and offers enhanced ride comfort and long-lasting tread life.

If you want to own a reliable set of all-season tires for your CUV or SUV, this BlackHawk Agility SUV vs Summit Trail Climber SUV2 tires comparison will be a great source of knowledge to help you decide which one aligns better with your driving needs, preferences, and budget. Here, we will use our in-house tire rating system, SimpleScore, to understand each tire’s overall ability, along with its performance in areas like traction, handling, and longevity on a scale of 0-10. Read on!

BlackHawk Agility SUV tires

The BlackHawk Agility SUV is made for drivers of CUVs and SUVs who seek a quieter and more stable highway driving experience. The tire sports an advanced all-season compound and a unique symmetric tread pattern for a dependable grip year-round in dry, wet, and light winter conditions. It is also optimized for better hydroplaning resistance, longer service life, and enhanced ride comfort for daily commuting.

Overall, the Agility SUV is rated a solid 8.0 SimpleScore, thanks to its dependable year-round traction, consistent handling, and great service life.

Get BlackHawk Agility SUV tires at the best deals for your vehicle here

Summit Trail Climber SUV2 tires

The Summit Trail Climber SUV2 is a capable all-season tire built to withstand the demands of modern SUVs and CUVs for a pleasant paved-road driving experience. The tire sports a computer-tuned tread pattern that offers solid contact with roads in rain, shine, and light snow. Alongside year-round traction, it is tuned for whisper-quiet rides, increased load-carrying capacity, increased stability, and longer wear.

Overall, the Trail Climber SUV2 earns an impressive 8.4 SimpleScore because of its impressive longevity, responsive handling, and great all-season traction.

Get Summit Trail Climber SUV2 tires at the best deals for your vehicle here

BlackHawk Agility SUV vs Summit Trail Climber SUV2 tires on traction

With the overviews of both tires covered, let’s now get into more details of these tires, starting with the traction analysis.

First, let’s talk about the Agility SUV, which secures an 8.0 SimpleScore in traction, assuring solid traction in dry, wet, and mild snowy conditions. The traction performance is enhanced by its dense network of sipes and sharper tread block edges that improve surface-biting ability on wet roads and light snow. The tread compound is specifically formulated to remain flexible, ensuring that the tire maintains a secure road connection during summer storms or chilly autumn mornings.

On the contrary, the Trail Climber SUV2 achieves a great 8.2 SimpleScore in traction. The computer-optimized tread pattern and multiple biting edges are designed to slice through water and light slush for a commanding year-round grip. Likewise, the specialized all-season compound allows the tire to hold the surface in rain, shine, and mild snow, ensuring optimum surefootedness.

While both tires offer year-round traction, the Trail Climber SUV2 takes the lead with a higher score and better performance.

ADVANTAGE: Summit Trail Climber SUV2

BlackHawk Agility SUV vs Summit Trail Climber SUV2 tires on handling

Now, let’s find out which of the two tires is better on the handling front and offers better ride control, stability, steering response, braking, and cornering throughout the year.

Commencing with the Agility SUV, the tire secures an 8.1 SimpleScore in handling. The tire manufacturer has optimized the tread with increased block rigidity and a stable center rib for a predictable steering feel and straight-line stability on paved surfaces. The internal structure of the tire is also reinforced enough to maintain its original shape under stress, ensuring controlled lane changes and confident maneuvers, especially on highways.

On the contrary, the Trail Climber SUV2 achieves a higher 8.3 SimpleScore for its better handling performance. The tread pattern of the tire is engineered for enhanced cornering stability and steering precision, for which it specifically utilizes rigid outer blocks. The tread pattern is tuned for increased contact with a surface, while the larger portion of the tread boosts ride control and reduces braking distances in dry and wet conditions.

In handling, the Trail Climber SUV2 takes the lead again, ensuring a more responsive and controlled driving experience.

ADVANTAGE: Summit Trail Climber SUV2

BlackHawk Agility SUV vs Summit Trail Climber SUV2 tires on longevity

Let’s now focus on the longevity area that helps tire buyers determine the value of a tire better. Here, we will learn which of the two tires is better when it comes to wear resistance and covering more miles. This was the area where the gap between the scores of the two tires was maximum. But which one excelled? Let’s find out!

Starting with the Agility SUV, the tire scores a great 8.1 SimpleScore in longevity. It is covered by a solid 60,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, underlining the brand's confidence in its service life and overall durability to resist wear. The optimized footprint is engineered to promote even wear and extend tread life during its use year-round.

Contrarily, the Trail Climber SUV2 surpasses its peers with a better and more impressive 9.0 SimpleScore for its outstanding longevity. This tire also comes with a 60,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, highlighting the tire’s ability to last longer. Thanks to the reinforced construction and abrasion-resistant rubber compound, the Trail Climber SUV2 slows down the wear rate to cover more miles.

While both tires are great in terms of longevity, it is again the Summit Trail Climber SUV2 that beats the Agility SUV by a 3-0, coming out as a clear winner here.

ADVANTAGE: Summit Trail Climber SUV2

When to use each

Both the Agility SUV and the Trail Climber SUV2 are touring all-season tires tuned for covering longer drives on highways in dry, wet, and light winter conditions on paved surfaces. Alongside year-round performance, these tires are also good when it comes to offering comfortable and quieter rides. That being said, none of these tires is Three Peak Mountain Snowflake (3PMSF) certified, and therefore, they should not be used in moderate to severe winter conditions, in temperatures below 45 degrees.

Talking about rim sizes, both the Agility SUV and Trail Climber SUV2 are available in 16- to 21-inch rim size options.

Which one should you choose?

Based on the overall SimpleScore, the Trail Climber SUV2 is a better tire than the Agility SUV (8.4 vs 8.0). However, it is to be noted that they both come with their unique abilities, which must be weighed based on your driving needs and budget.

As far as the prices are concerned, the Agility SUV is offered at an initial price of at least $85 per tire, while the Trail Climber SUV2 is offered at a starting price of at least $83 per tire. This means you get a set of four BlackHawk tires at a starting price of at least $340, while a set of four Summit tires will cost you at least $332.

Looking at SimpleScore, you should choose the BlackHawk Agility SUV if you:

• Drive a vehicle like the Toyota RAV4, Honda CR-V, or Nissan Rogue.
• Need a tire that has a marginally affordable starting price and offers reliable all-season performance.
• Need a tire that’s backed by an equally good tread life warranty.

On the other hand, you should consider the Summit Trail Climber SUV2 if you:

• Drive a vehicle like the Chevrolet Equinox, Ford Explorer, or Mazda CX-5.
• Want a tire that’s better in longevity (9.0 vs 8.1).
• Want a tire that’s better in traction (8.2 vs 8.0).
• Want a tire that’s better in handling (8.3 vs 8.1).

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help, as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.